Skip to main content

Table 4 Summary table of scope of included reviews and assessments of selected CEESAT categories

From: What secondary research evidence exists on the effects of forest management after disturbances: a systematic map protocol

Review year

RI1

Aim primary objective

No. of stud

Region2

DA3

protocol?

(2.1)4

Search comprehensive (3.2)4

Eligibility criteria defined (4.1)4

Critical appraisal (5.1)4

Limitations discussed (8.1)4

Name1and Name2 (2012) 5

1

Investigate the effect of salvage logging on tree regeneration

21

Global

 

Name 3 et al. 2019

5

a

…

        
  1. The final publication will also provide a table with the full CEESAT assessments for every included review and a table template is provided here as Additional file 4
  2. 1Review Identifier; number: reference with meta-analysis (quantitative synthesis), letter: reference with narrative synthesis (qualitative synthesis) following[30]
  3. 2Global, Tropical, Temperate, Boreal
  4. 3Disturbance Agent: all, drought, fire, wind, ice and snow, pathogens, insects, herbivores, harvest
  5. 4based on CEESAT. Number in brackets refers to the section in CEESAT (2020, Version 2.1): Is there an a-priori method/protocol document? (2.1); Is the search comprehensive? (3.2); Are eligibility criteria clearly defined? (4.1); Does the review critically appraise each study? (5.1); Have the authors considered limitations of the synthesis? (8.1)
  6. 5article access issues: open book indicates open access and closed book indicates some form of subscription
Back to article page

Environmental Evidence

ISSN: 2047-2382